As I watched the video "A Tale of Two Schools" I was disgusted and amazed that things like these still go on in one of the richest countries in the world. It was sad to see the educational system that these children face, and it was even sadder to think that the cycle of poor education and living circumstances in some situations, would not come to an end.
The students from both of the schools in Mississippi and Texas, had a lot of problems in their education system. There were lack of supplies, lack of support, and lack of training for the teachers; especially for the teachers in Mississippi. However, I did notice dedicated teachers who wanted the best for their students and was really trying their best to make things work.
Both The Reading Mastery Program and Project Read need a lot of work in order for them to really benefit their students. I do not see either of these programs being used in the context that they were being used in those classrooms, in any rich or upper-class school district. However, if I had to choose one, I would choose Project Read. Although The Reading Mastery Program seemed to be more organized, I find Project Read to be for flexible, and more relevant to the way we read. The Reading Mastery Program had weird markings in order to help the children read, and it had no room for adjustment, trial, and error. In my opinion, with the correct training, management skills, and enthusiastic energy, Project Read can be a success. Though it do have its flaws, the program has potential in my eyes, and has the ability to be effective. With help from parents, and support from the teachers, the students are definitely able to learn, grow, and excel.
Leshelle,
ReplyDeleteI kind of had the same reaction to the video. I think it is incredible that with the circumstances we see in both schools there are still teachers who come each day and work as hard as they can to reach all students. I also think it's great to see students who really want to work hard and learn even when they may be going through tough times outside of school. It's probably the dedication from the teachers and a safe environment that make the students want to be there.
Leshelle,
ReplyDeleteI felt the same way watching the video. I was so upset to see kids struggling so much and lacking the tools they needed to succeed. The teachers, however, seemed so dedicated and involved in making sure the students did their best which I thought was great.
I think you bring up some interesting points about Project Read. I chose Reading Mastery as the program I would like to teach, but I think you make some valid points about Project Read. I felt as though it was very unorganized and confusing, but like you said with training and structure I think it could be successful and effective.